• Post last modified:August 24, 2020
  • Reading time:14 mins read
  • Post comments:0 Comments

There are hundreds of kitchen appliances on the market, so choosing a toaster oven with good quality, a high-cost performance that is also suitable for your needs is not easy.

The purpose of this evaluation is to help you narrow down the scope to find the best toaster oven for your needs.

In order to get as accurate information as possible, we have collected more than a dozen countertop toaster ovens from Amazon according to their ratings and screened them according to their popularity in the market. After reading, you can refer to the user reviews and actual experiences to find the most important functions, advantages, and disadvantages of each toaster oven.

After a comprehensive comparison and analysis of all the collected data, we have screened out our 8 best countertop toaster ovens in the United States, hoping to help you to make the right decision with your next purchase.

Why do you need a countertop toaster oven?

Large ovens are generally installed in the kitchens of European and American families, but many people also have a countertop toaster oven in their homes, which is often more frequently used than their large ovens. Why?

Here are some of the main reasons why toaster ovens are so popular collected from hundreds of user feedbacks:

  • Energy savings: These countertop toaster ovens can save up to 50% of cooking energy compared to large ovens.
  • Time-saving: Shorter preheating and cooking time.
  • Easy to use: It’s more convenient than a large oven.
  • Safer: Compared to a large oven, a toaster oven is safe to use and has less chance of being burned.

In my experience, having a big oven in summer also raises the indoor temperature and increases power consumption especially when used with the air conditioner.

On the other hand, the use of a small oven only marginally affects the temperature of a room.

The best countertop toaster ovens

How to choose a countertop toaster oven?

When choosing a toaster oven, you should consider the following points:

  • How much do you want to spend?
  • Is it easy to clean?
  • Is it easy to use?
  • Is the baking time reasonable?
  • What size do you need?

1. Price

The price range can run from $30 to $1,000, depending on their quality and specific functions.

If you just want an oven to cook breakfast, or a simple baking and heating function, there is no need to spend too much on it.

The ovens with more functionality are usually more expensive, with better quality and durability.

2. Useful accessories

Most models of toaster ovens are equipped with crumb trays, oven racks, and bakeware. Some ovens come with a convection function and may also have multiple racks or additional bakeware.

There can be a lot of food crumbs during the cooking process, so the ease of disassembling the tray and cleaning the oven is also a point to consider.

3. The uniqueness of the oven

The most basic functions of an oven are grilling, baking, and reheating. They all have their own unique settings, such as the ability to set the precise temperature and time required to bake different foods.

Convection is another very convenient and useful function. This type of oven has a fan and exhaust system to help circulate the hot air in the oven, making food cook faster and better.

4. Capacity and size 

It should be noted that the performance of baking and cooking and energy consumption depends on the size of the oven.

For those who only need simple functions, an oven with a smaller capacity and size may be more suitable.

For people who have a large family, or who like to bake and cook different kinds of food, they may need a larger multi-function oven.

In short, choose the right size oven according to your family’s needs, size, and financial situation.

The best countertop toaster ovens on the market:

According to their different characteristics, we have screened out the 8 most popular toaster ovens on the market.

1.Breville Bov800xl Smart Oven – Best overall.

2.BLACK+DECKER Countertop – Best low-cost toaster oven.

3.Breville BOV900BSS Convection & Air Fry – Best 2-in-1 air fryer oven

4.Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven – Best for small kitchens.

5.Panasonic NB-G110P FlashXpress – Fastest cooking oven.

6.Oster Digital Convection Toaster Oven – Best for large families.

7.Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven– Easiest to use and clean.

8.Black and Decker TO1950SBD -Best on a budget.

Below is a comparison table of these countertop toaster ovens:

Productcapacityconvection
Breville Bov800xl6 slices of toast, 13-inch pizzayes
BLACK+DECKER6 slices of toast, 12-inch pizzayes
Breville BOV900BSS9 slices of toast, 12-inch pizzayes
Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven4 slices of toast, 11-inch pizzano
Panasonic NB-G110P4 slices of toast, 9-inch pizzano
Oster Digital Toaster Oven6 slices of toast, 12-inch pizzayes
Hamilton Beach6 slices of toast, 12-inch pizzayes
Black+Decker TO1950SBD6 slices of toast, 9-inch pizzayes

1.Breville Bov800xl Smart Oven – Best overall

the best countertop toaster ovens

This is the most popular, and the most cost-effective toaster oven on the market. It is also one of the most used small kitchen appliances in my home.

Breville Bov800xl is very powerful but easy to use. From baking to grilling, you can make almost anything with it.

The Smart Oven with Element iQ technology, can automatically adjust the power according to the ingredients that bake the perfect pizza, delicious cookies, toasts evenly and roasts succulent meat.

Its convection function makes the heat distribution in the whole oven more even, so that the baked food has good appearance and taste.

Function dial with 9 preset cooking functions includes toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, and warm.

You can select the precise time, temperature, and cooking method for specific types of food through these nine functions.

[Accessories]

  • 12” x 12” enamel broil rack
  • 12” x 12” enamel baking pan
  • 13” non-stick pizza pan
  • Crumb tray

[Pros]

  • Easy to clean.
  • Non-Stick Interior with 3 rack positions.
  • Tempered glass door.
  • Magnetic auto-eject rack.
  • Temperature and time dial with auto shut-off and sound alert.
  • Powerful.
  • Even heat distribution.
  • Easy to operate.

[Cons] 

  • The price is relatively high.
  • It is not easy to equip spare parts after failure.

2.BLACK+DECKER Countertop – Best low-cost toaster oven

Top toaster ovens

If you don’t want to spend too much, but want to get most of the functions, then this oven will be more suitable for you.

The capacity of this toaster oven is not too small. It also has a convection fan, so that the food is heated more evenly and cooked faster.

With eight preset functions, it can satisfy simple grilling, baking, heating, and heat preservation work. The control panel is easy to operate and can precisely control the cooking time and temperature.

There is a crumb tray that can slide in and out at the bottom of the oven that makes it easy to clean any food residue.

[Accessories]

  • Dual-position rack
  • Bake pan (drip tray)
  • Broil rack
  • Crumb tray

[Pros]

  • Affordable.
  • Internal hot air convection design helps heat food more evenly.
  • Multi-functions.
  • Spacious internal space.
  • Easy to operate.
  • Fast heating speed.

[Cons]

  • The texts on the control panel may easily wear off.
  • It can be a little difficult to remove the food after it’s cooked.

3.Breville Convection & Air Fry – The best 2-in-1 air fryer oven

Breville BOV900BSS Convection and Air Fry Smart Oven

This 2-in-1 air fryer toaster oven is an upgraded version of the first oven mentioned.

It comes with the dual functions of an air fryer and an oven and comes in 4 different sizes. It doesn’t matter how big your kitchen counter is, because you can always find one that is suitable for your needs.

It can replace traditional ovens and air fryers meet almost all the needs of baking, grilling, frying, as well as heat preservation and reheating. The functions are very comprehensive.

There are four-layer grill notches on the inner wall of the oven. With that option, you can adjust the position of the grill and the baking tray according to different ingredients and cooking needs.

If you don’t have a lot of space in your kitchen, or you don’t want to keep many kitchen appliances, this 2-in-1 multi-function toaster oven may be worth having.

It’s more costly because of its powerful functions and also because it’s the largest model. However, you can choose a different size according to your financial situation and actual needs.

[Accessories]

  • 13″ non-stick pizza pan
  • Wire rack (x 2)
  • 9″ x 13″ broiling rack
  • 9″ x 13″ enamel roasting pan
  • Air fry/dehydrate basket
  • Crumb tray

[Pros] 

  • Has dual functions of air fryer and oven.
  • With Element iQ technology.
  • Precision cooking.
  • Fast cooking speed.
  • Large LCD display.
  • Large capacity.

[Cons]

  • Higher price. 
  • The door doesn’t always close properly.
  • It may be pretty loud during operation.

4.Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven – Best for small kitchens

For those families with tight kitchen space, this compact and versatile toaster oven can meet your needs.

This oven has eight cooking functions including bagel, toast, bake, broil, pizza, roast, cookies, and reheat.

It also has Element IQ technology design, which can automatically adjust the cooking temperature intelligently across 4 quartz elements for precise and stable heat, resulting in perfect results, every time. 

The inner wall of the oven has a non-stick coating for easy cleaning.

[Accessories]

  • 10” x 10” enamel baking pan
  • Ribbed plate warming tray
  • Crumb tray

[Pros]

  • Small size, and does not take up too much space.
  • Heats food evenly.
  • Great value for money.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Easy to use.
  • Suitable for small families with one to two people, or small kitchens. 

[Cons]

  • The shell may get hot during operation.

5.Panasonic NB-G110P FlashXpress – Fastest cooking oven

This small toaster oven is easy to use and heats up quickly and evenly. It is suitable for a family of one or two people.

It has ceramic and quartz infrared heating elements that can instantly heat up, so the cooking speed is 40% faster than traditional ovens. There is no need to preheat. After setting the temperature, you can put food in immediately.

When the oven door opens, it brings the rack out together, so you can easily take food out without worrying about being scalded. Many people like this feature.

There are 6 preset buttons with illustrations, which are very intuitive and automatically calculate the cooking time of various foods. The heating range is wide, starting from 250°F and going to 500°F (121°C-260°C).

It also comes with a removable food crumb tray for easy cleaning.

One drawback is that this toaster oven does not have a cancel button. This means that once the cooking starts, it cannot be stopped midway unless the power is cut off. This seems somewhat inconvenient.

[Accessories]

  • Oven rack
  • Baking tray
  • Crumb tray

[Pros]

  • Small size, and doesn’t take too much space. 
  • Suitable for small families.
  • Fast cooking, save your time.
  • Automatically calculate the cooking time.
  • Wide temperature setting range.
  • Low power consumption.

[Cons]

  • Small internal space.
  • Stuttering may occur when adjusting the temperature.

6.Oster Digital Convection Toaster Oven – Best for large families

This is a large-capacity, multi-function oven, with a black stainless steel shell. The stylish design is one of the reasons for its popularity.

It has a wide controllable temperature range, from 150°F to 450°F (66°C-230°C), and is equipped with the most advanced electronic control device with 7 cooking settings.

In addition to the most basic baking function, there is also a defrosting function, which means it can replace your microwave oven.

It also comes with a detachable tray for easy cleaning.

Additionally, much of the feedback has mentioned that its convection fan is relatively quiet. Therefore, this toaster oven is considered to be quieter than most other models.

[Accessories]

  • Removable Wire Rack
  • Baking Pan
  • Broiling Rack 
  • Crumb Tray

[Pros]

  • Excellent value for money.
  • Strong functions.
  • Easy to use.
  • Stylish design.
  • Fast cooking speed.
  • Low power consumption.
  • Suitable for larger families.

[Cons] 

  • The shell may get hot.
  • The power cord is a little short.

7.Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven  – Easiest to use and clean

 

This is another relatively economical toaster oven.

Its biggest feature is a distinctive roll-top door, which opens upwards, not downwards like other ovens. Thus, it will not take up extra countertop space. It is also convenient when taking out the food which can help to avoid burns.

This Hamilton Beach oven is relatively simple. Although it does not have many features like other high-end models, such as digital control panels and preset cooking functions, it is still excellent for grilling and baking with uniform heating and fast cooking.

In addition, its small size makes it suitable for limited countertop space. However, the capacity is large enough to hold 6 slices of toast or a 12-inch pizza.

Unlike many other toaster ovens, this oven allows you to choose between baking and convection. The baking feature is great for making delicious cakes and desserts. Then you can use convection for crisp, golden-brown pizza and for an evenly cooked caramelized crust on baked goods.

The downside is that the door that opens upwards does not have a spring pull, so it could slide down. You need to be careful when using it. Open the oven door completely before letting it go.

[Accessories]

  • Baking/Broiling Pan
  • Toasting/Baking/Broiling Oven Rack
  • Crumb tray

[Pros] 

  • The special door design is convenient to take out your food.
  • Easy and simple to operate.
  • Easy to clean.
  • Features a 30-minute timer with auto shut off.
  • Heating evenly.
  • Small size, and doesn’t take up too much space.

[Cons] 

  • The height inside the oven is limited.
  • It’s pretty loud when operating.

8.Black and Decker TO1950SBD – Best on a budget

 

This may be the most affordable high-performance oven you can find. If you only need a simple oven with simple functions, don’t miss this one.

This toaster oven uses convection technology to distribute heat evenly. Although there are only 4 functions — Bake, Broil, Toast and Keep Warm, it can meet your most basic baking needs.

With a 30-minute timer function, it is convenient for the timing of short-time cooking.

[Accessories]

  • Bake pan/drip tray 
  • Baking rack
  • Crumb tray

[Pros]

  • Affordable.
  • Small-sized, it doesn’t take too much space.
  • With a timer.
  • Simple and easy to use.
  • Heating evenly.
  • Easy to clean.

[Cons]

  • The shell can be hot when it’s running.
  • It’s not very durable.

Common mistakes when using toaster ovens:

Countertop toaster ovens are popular, high-usage small kitchen appliances. You want them to be more robust and last longer.

However, if you don’t use it properly, its service life will be shortened and even could be dangerous.

1. Not reading the user manual carefully.

When you purchase a toaster oven, it comes with a user manual. You need to spend some time reading it before using the oven. Especially the content regarding the correct usage method and safety tips.

2. Failure to clean up food residues in time.

After using the oven, some food scraps and stains, such as bread crumbs, oil drops, etc., will often fall into it. If they are not cleaned up in time, this can affect the efficiency of the oven and accumulate excessive dryness. Debris may also be ignited at high temperatures.

It is best to wipe down the inside of the oven after each use, at the very least it is necessary to clean the crumb tray.

3. Overload work.

If the oven can only hold 4 slices of bread, putting 6 slices in it will not only affect the baking effect but also increase the workload of the oven.

4. Using containers with the wrong material.

There have been reports in the past that a toaster oven in use suddenly caught fire.

Just like metal objects cannot be used in a microwave oven, do not use flammable containers, such as paper towels, paper plates, plastic plates, etc. in a toaster oven.

Above summarizes the Best Countertop Toaster Ovens on the market. I hope this information can help you choose the most satisfactory product.


Leave a Reply